What
a relief….. I’ve finally started
teaching. I’ve got some volunteer
teaching hours on the Diploma in Foundation Studies in Art and Design at
Swansea Met. The staff members are
great; very welcoming and helpful so I think everything will be fine. The students are cool; they seem hard
working, focused and talented. I’ve just
spent the morning with them and two main things occurred to me. Firstly, I was really impressed with the
quality of the student’s work in terms of creativity and the processes and
techniques used. Secondly, I was struck
by the nature of the students in terms of both their behaviour and
attitude. In my previous position most
of the students I worked with had not achieved well educationally and many had
unstable, challenging home lives and difficult relationships. Due to this at times learning was not a
priority for these students. This is in
contrast to the students on the Foundation Diploma course who are already
successful learners, the majority of them have passed A Levels, so have a
positive view of themselves as being able to achieve on a course of study. They also appear to have more settled home
lives and successful relationships.
These
thoughts made me think of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs (1954).
“Maslow, whose
work is closely related to humanistic psychology saw ‘self-actualization’ as
what drives people to learn; that is the need to make full use of one’s
talents, become creative and achieve one’s potential is what motivates us.
Self-actualization is an ultimate human goal and need, but before that need can
be fulfilled a set of other needs must be met” (Armitage et al, 2007: 66).
On
the Foundation Learning programme a minority of the students may not even have had
their most basic needs met (hunger and thirst), some may not have achieved the
next level (physical and psychological well-being) while others may not have
achieved the next level (love and belonging).
I think students on the Foundation Diploma course do have a sense of
love and belonging and some also have self-esteem. If you are don’t feel secure then learning
may not seem important, even though it may be a way to move up a level or two. Understanding what motivates, or holds students
back, is useful as it can inform your teaching strategies and your approach.
However, there are a number of issues with the
Maslow model when it is applied to real-life situations. For example, as each person is unique so
individuals seem to respond to several needs and not just one and this may
change over time.
References
Armitage, A., Byant, R.,
Dunnill, R., Hayes, D., Hudson, A., Kent, J., Lawes, S. & Renwick, M. (2007)
Teaching and Training in Post-Compulsory
Education, 3rd Ed, Maidenhead: Open University Press.